Since it’s October, I thought I’d focus on some thriller/mystery-type books. The Witch Elm is the fourth book I’ve read by Tana French. The other three were in the Dublin Murder Squad series and the first two were good but the third was not my favorite. Side note – the first two were made into a tv series if you’ve read them or are just interested in those kind of shows.
The Witch Elm has a couple different story lines that seem to intertwine at times but doesn’t seem to at others. The main character, Toby, along with his family are rocked by his uncle’s brain tumor diagnosis and are preparing for the end of his life. Just before to the diagnosis, Toby is attacked in his home and barely makes it out alive, so decides to go live with his uncle for a while during his recovery. However, a giant wrench is thrown into everyone’s recovery and end of life plans (respectively) when human remains are found on his uncle’s property.
And investigation ensues and the detectives appear to try to set Toby and his cousins against one another by feeding various information and tips and asking specific questions about the remains that turn out to be an old classmate of Toby and his cousins. I won’t give away everything, but in the end they get a confession, though the whole situation has incredible repercussions on Toby.
Overall, I thought the story was a little predictable and very outlandish. Obviously it’s fiction, but I at least like for my whodunit stories to have a bit of believable content. I also thought it jumped around too much (which I guess may have been on purpose to mimic the main character’s brain injury) and had a lot of holes. If you’re wanting to read Tana French, I wouldn’t start with this one. So I’ve enjoyed 2 of 4 books by her. May take a break on hers for a little while but I’ll leave them on my list to maybe try again in the future.